Email Us
Map Location

Analyzing Email Marketing Metrics for Success

Business Development

So, you've been pouring your heart and soul into crafting the perfect emails. You've spent countless hours nitpicking subject lines, tinkering with templates, and mastering your calls to action. Finally, you decide to hit “send” after reviewing everything.  

The hard part is done, right? Wrong.  

Without understanding email marketing metrics, you're navigating this complex world blindfolded. It's like baking a sumptuous cake but not bothering to taste it. The creation is only half the journey; the real fun (and knowledge) is in the tasting!

Email marketing isn’t just about creating engaging content, pressing the “send” button, and hoping for the best. It's about understanding your audience, figuring out what makes them tick, and delivering value straight into their inbox.  

So, get ready to roll up your sleeves as we take a deep dive into the world of email marketing. By the end of this post, you can confidently say that you can transform your email game from “just trying it out” to “nailing it like a pro.” Let’s get the ball rolling!

Breaking Down the Key Metrics

Keeping an eye on certain email marketing metrics is a crucial step you wouldn’t want to skip. These metrics help you identify what’s working and what needs tweaking. Let’s take an in-depth look at each of them below:

1. Open Rate

The first frontier of your email marketing campaign's success, the open rate, is the percentage of recipients who actually open your email out of the total number of emails delivered. It's a great way to measure the initial impact of your email, primarily driven by the effectiveness of your subject line and sender name.

A low open rate might indicate your subject lines aren't compelling enough or that your sender name doesn't resonate with your audience. Maybe you're not triggering curiosity, or perhaps your email is getting lost in the sea of other emails.  

Whatever the case, understanding your open rates can help you strategize better and devise more appealing subject lines or sender names.


Open rate = (number of emails opened ÷ number of emails delivered) ✕ 100%

Ways to Boost Your Email Open Rate:

  • Craft compelling subject lines. Your subject line is the first thing recipients see, so make it count. Aim to pique curiosity, offer value, or incite urgency.
  • Personalize your emails. Personalization goes beyond just using the recipient's name. Tailor your content to their preferences or past behavior for a more engaging experience.
  • Optimize your send time. Find out when your audience will most likely check their emails and schedule your sends accordingly. This can vary depending on factors like your industry, audience demographics, and more.
  • Segment your list. Different segments of your audience may be interested in different types of content. Segmenting your list allows you to tailor your emails to different groups, potentially increasing open rates.
  • Improve your sender reputation. Consistently sending high-quality, relevant content can help improve your reputation with email service providers, making it more likely your emails reach the inbox.
  • Choose a familiar sender name. Since people tend to open emails from names they recognize, use a consistent, familiar sender name to build trust with your subscribers.

2. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

hand clicking on a mouse

CTR is like the cool cousin of open rates. It shows the percentage of folks who didn't just open your email but those who actually clicked on one or more links in it.  

It's not just about "Hey, they opened my email!" but more about "Whoa, they liked my content enough to click on it!" In short, CTR gives you a peek into who's really engaging with your content and who's just stopping by. Use this metric to refine your content and provide value your audience can't resist clicking on.

If you have a high CTR, great! Your content resonates with your audience. If your CTR is low, it could indicate your email content isn't compelling enough or your links aren't enticing.  


Click-through rate = (number of clicks ÷ number of emails delivered) ✕ 100%

Ways to Boost Your CTR:

  • Highlight benefits, not features. Don't just list the features of your product or service. Tell your audience how it can solve their problems or make their lives more convenient.
  • Produce engaging content. This could be powerful storytelling, useful information, engaging questions, or even humor - whatever suits your brand and resonates with your audience.
  • Design for easy reading. Break up your text into small, easily digestible sections. Use bullet points, headings, and bold or italic fonts to emphasize key points.
  • Include multiple links. The more opportunities for clicking, the better. Include links within your text, images, and of course, your CTA.

Conversion Rate

Now, let's talk about the conversion rate. It’s where the party really starts in email marketing.  

You may see people clicking on your links but don’t get too excited yet. It’s about what they do next. Do they make a purchase? Sign up for a subscription? Fill out a form? That's what your conversion rate measures - the percentage of email recipients who clicked on a link and then went the extra mile to complete a desired action.  

If your conversion rates are low despite high open rates and CTR, it might be time to reevaluate your call-to-action (CTA). Is it clear and compelling? Is the landing page relevant to the email content? Or perhaps the user experience on your website needs tweaking. Whatever the reason, identifying and improving it could significantly increase your conversions.


Conversion rate = (number of actions completed ÷ number of emails delivered) ✕ 100%

Ways to Boost Your Conversion Rate:

  • Keep your CTAs clear and compelling. Your calls to action should be irresistible. Use action-oriented language and make it crystal clear what's in it for the reader.
  • Prioritize relevance. The content of your email should match up with the CTA. If someone clicked through expecting one thing and got another, don’t expect them to convert.
  • Simplify the process. Less friction means higher chances of users taking action. Make the conversion process (like checkout or form fill) as straightforward as possible.
  • Leverage social proof. Reviews, testimonials, and case studies can provide that extra reassurance to push someone to click the CTA button.
  • Add urgency and scarcity. If appropriate, create a sense of urgency or scarcity (limited-time offer, only a few items left, etc.) to motivate immediate action.

Bounce Rate

man holding tablet with bounce rate word on top

The “unsung hero” of email marketing metrics; the bounce rate reveals the percentage of your emails that went out for a little trip but couldn't make their way into the recipient's inbox.

There are two types of bounces, hard and soft. Hard bounces are like a permanent "no-entry" sign; they happen when the email address is either wrong or doesn't exist. Soft bounces, on the other hand, are like temporary roadblocks. They occur because of temporary issues, like when the recipient's inbox is too full to accommodate your email.

A high bounce rate is a red flag you can't ignore. It's like a blot on your sender reputation, and it can hurt your chances of delivering emails in the future. That's why it's super important to keep your email list spick-and-span, removing invalid addresses or ones that consistently bounce.  


Bounce rate = (number of emails bounced ÷ number of emails sent) ✕ 100%

Ways to Reduce Your Bounce Rate:

  • Clean your email list regularly. Remove inactive subscribers and those who have not engaged with your emails in a long time.
  • Use double opt-in. This is a process where subscribers need to confirm their email address after signing up, reassuring you that you're sending emails to valid addresses.
  • Avoid spam traps. Don't purchase email lists or scrape emails from the web. These can include spam trap addresses that can harm your sender reputation.
  • Check for typos. You may be surprised to learn that something as simple as a typo can lead to a bounce. So, see to it that you check your list for common misspellings and correct them.

Unsubscribe Rate

Last on our list, but certainly not least, is the unsubscribe rate. It's like the audience feedback on your email marketing performance, indicating the percentage of people who opt out of your emails after receiving a particular campaign. It's like saying, "Thanks, but no thanks" to your content.

A high unsubscribe rate is certainly something you don’t want to see. It could be a sign that your content isn't resonating with your audience, or worse – it's annoying them.  

Don’t get too disheartened by unsubscribes, though. It's a natural part of email marketing, and even the best campaigns will see some unsubscribes. However, a sudden spike or consistently high unsubscribe rate is cause for concern and warrants a deeper look into your email marketing practices.


Unsubscribe rate = (number of unsubscribes ÷ number of emails delivered) ✕ 100%

Ways to Reduce Your Unsubscribe Rate:

  • Deliver on your promises. See to it that you're sending the content your subscribers signed up for. If they expect something you promised and get something different, they might hit that unsubscribe button.
  • Don't overwhelm your subscribers. Too many emails can lead to subscriber fatigue. Find a frequency that works for your audience and stick to it.
  • Segment and personalize. Tailor your emails to the interests and behaviors of your subscribers. The more relevant your content, the less likely they are to unsubscribe.
  • Create engaging and valuable content. Aim to entertain, inspire, educate, or help your subscribers. Emails that provide value give subscribers a reason to stick around.
  • Offer preferences option. Give your subscribers more control by allowing them to choose what kind of emails they receive and how often.  

Let’s Propel Your Email Marketing to New Heights

what are you waiting for written on blackboard

Well, there you have it – a deep dive into the key metrics of email marketing and how to make them work for your success. Mastering these metrics is like learning a new language, the language of your audience. You can communicate effectively once you understand it, driving engagement and, ultimately, growth.

Then again, email marketing can seem like a juggling act, and that's why we're here to offer a hand.  

At Digital Resource, we're pros in email marketing, content creation, and all things digital. We know the ins and outs of these metrics, and we're pretty good at that juggling act. We'll craft personalized email campaigns, create engaging content, analyze those key metrics, and make data-driven decisions to steer your brand to online success.  

Ready to elevate your email marketing game? Contact us today so we can start turning those metrics into results!

Back to blogs

Related Blogs

Want to work for us?

Think you've got what it takes to hang with the pros at Digital Resource? Check out our Careers page to browse current job openings!

apply Today
Digital Resource Awards